i-tsari-tsu-i wrote:
Wayne,
It seems possible that one person carved the figures and another did the lettering. As I have mentioned many times before, the fact that the heart is removed (plucked) from the Stone Maps is, to me, an important clue to the creators.
The fact that the Stone Map Trail goes right through the middle of the Harry LaFrance search area for the cave of gold bars is another important clue. One of the markings on the side of that trail might just be his cave.
There is a pretty good piece of evidence connecting Ted to the LaFrance Family. I believe you have seen it. The fact that finding any documented history of any LaFrance in Arizona leads to only one (1) person, and he is found in Tucson, Ted's stomping grounds, seems a bit
of a coincidence. It may be that that is all it is, but I like the direction it seems to point.
That being said, I would not bet the farm on that story, but I would also not bet the farm against it being a valid clue.
It remains an interesting theory, at least to me. I have high hopes that someone else will pick up on the story, with more energy and smarts than I, and see if it goes anywhere.
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to you and your's as well.
Take care,
Joe
Joe:
The Stone Maps were not likely to have been carved in haste,or by one person.
I doubt any of us will ever know the facts as to who carved what,or exactly when.
I'm not sure that a signed copy of a book,possibly done at a book-signing in 1976..long after the Stones became widely known..is particularly strong evidence of a LaFrance/DeGrazia connection to the Stone Maps.Nor do I see where both having resided in Tucson is any more than a tenuous link.
They both were interested in the Superstitions,lost treasure,and probably the Stone maps as well.
As countless others have been since they were found by Tumlinson.
Is there evidence that they were friends before 1948/9 ?
Did deGrazia ever mention LaFrance or his cave in any publication?
Is there any photograph of them together?
That kind of evidence would be less ambiguous.
Chuck Aylor's favorite Shakespearian quote may have been the result of his interest in the stones,as opposed to the stones being the the result of his interest in Shakepeare.
I have a favorite quote as well,also from Hamlet..."The lady doth protest too much, methinks."
It's one which I have been reminded of many times while hearing others claim their opinion,their "Trail",or that of others as a
"fact"....repetitiously in fact.
Aylor may have had it wrong,though.
While the Heart Stones can be removed from the Trail Map,they can also be placed within the cavity,something that to me makes more sense.
For both hearts,red and black,IMO.
I once shared some of your suspicions about DG and the maps.
Others have as well,and have searched the mountains for evidence and published their theories.
One such is:
http://books.google.ca/books?id=sckq9Ej ... edir_esc=yThe author makes a case for the LDM,and the many maps as well as the Stone Maps being modern creations of the Don's Club and DeGrazia.
Throw Bob Ward's story about DeGrazia's buried paintings into the mix though,and more theories might come into play as well.
Regards:Wayne